Why You Are Not Having Success With Contingency Recruiters

If you haven't worked with a recruiter in the past, you might not be aware that there are different types of recruiting services. Contingency, Retained and Engaged are the three main types of recruiting available. Like everything in life, each has situations where it excels and makes sense.

Certain companies only use one type of service, usually based on their needs and past experience. Of the three types, contingency is probably the most well known and more frequently used.


Why Contingency Is Often Preferred

Basically – you don't pay a fee unless the recruiter finds you a candidate to hire. So, you might interview 15 people they submit and not hire one. The recruiter has done all of their work for free. This is seen by many companies as a no-risk recruiting solution.

When you don't need to have someone yesterday or your hiring requirements are less rigid, contingency could be a great option. Usually, contingency works well for low-level management roles, sales needs, customer service, etc. It can come in handy when you need some hiring assistance but not enough to bring on a full-time HR or hiring manager. If you are looking for someone to find candidates, screen resumes and submit them, contingency could be a good bet.

So, yes, sometimes no hire/no fee works well. But, it isn't your only option and it can be the wrong choice at times.

Why Contingency May Not Be Your Best Bet

Reading about contingency search may make it appear to be the obvious choice. Why pay an upfront fee when there is no guarantee of results?

I often find people new to using recruiters have this mind set. And I totally get it. You want proof before you pay. You want to know a recruiter is worth the fees and that proof is in sending you top-notch candidates.

But consider that a recruiter doesn't get paid unless you make a hire. If the recruiter feels your search will be very difficult or a more lucrative one lands on their desk, yours probably goes to the bottom of their pile. In other words, you get what you pay for. They may work your search but they aren't going to put their heart and soul into it if they aren't guaranteed payment.

Where Contingency Can Fail

Contingency is absolutely a good solution for some roles. It can be a great way to get some hiring help, see candidates you might not have access to and help you manage parts of your hiring process.

But, there are times when it probably won't meet your expectations:

  • When you have extremely urgent needs
  • If you have high value/high importance roles to fill
  • When you have many positions to hire for
  • When you have a variety of openings to fill
  • If you are looking for experienced upper management or executives
  • When you have made multiple hiring mistakes and need to get it right
  • When you have exceedingly high criteria – needle in a haystack

If you recognize your company in any of those statements and you aren't having success, you probably need to look beyond contingency.

What Else Is There

Consider Retained and Engaged recruiting services when you are looking for upper management and executives, have rigid time constraints or position requirements and when you have multiple roles to fill. Paying an engagement fee or retainer means you have a recruiter's full attention and you can be sure you are at the top of their searches. Also, when your hiring needs go beyond just finding and screening candidates look beyond contingency.

If you are using a contingency recruiter and not seeing the results you want, it may be time to consider the alternatives.



Related Posts

Never Settle For The Best That Applied Again!

Learn my simple framework to get more qualified applicants for every job opening without breaking the bank or spending time you don’t have.

Recent Posts


About Rikka

Rikka’s the go-to girl for growth-minded Building Products Owners and Executives who want to hire the right people to take their manufacturing, distribution, or retail business to the next level.

Let's Talk

Looking for expert help?

Schedule a call to learn more about our training, coaching, and consulting opportunities.


An e-newsletter for leaders in the building products industry who want to hire better, lead stronger, and work smarter. Every other week you can expect relevant tips, insights, and news that will help you succeed as a leader.

Let's Connect

What are you looking for?

Interested in learning about how we can maximize your results on your recruiting and retention efforts?

Are you a building products professional? If so, confidentially register with us.